Conflicting opinions of expert witnesses: resolution thereof; principle applied and approach followed in deciding which opinion is preferable; principle applied and approach followed reaffirmed. On 21 May , and at the Strand, Malan executed a last will and testament. In the same will Malan made a further bequest of an amount of R10 to the Bible Society of South Africa; a further bequest of an amount of R5 to the Strand Service Centre; and a further bequest of an amount of R5 to the Christian Social Council. The residue of her estate was to devolve to Marie Heyns and Floris Burger, her niece and nephew, respectively, in equal shares. In terms of the disputed will Malan bequeathed to Van der Merwe an amount equivalent to the amount which would be due and owing to Malan, ostensibly arising from an acknowledgment of debt executed by Van der Merwe in favour of Malan on 14 September On 14 September Van der Merwe executed an acknowledgement of debt in favour of Malan. In terms of that acknowledgement of debt Van der Merwe acknowledged being truly and lawfully indebted to Malan in an amount of R arising from a sale of the property situate at and commonly known as number 13 Jacoma Court, Coast Road, Strand, for an amount of R less renovations and improvements in an amount of R45 effected thereon. The plaintiffs allege that the signature of Malan, as well as the signatures of the witnesses, appended on the first page of the disputed will, had been forged; and that the first page of the disputed will was not validly signed and, thus, stands to be declared invalid.
Handwriting Expert Witnesses: Their Role, Value, and Admissibility
Ink, as well. Our services, and handwriting experts. In reaching a particularly challenging forensic. It tends to identify. Relative dating of documents.
Forensic science may help you keep a level playing field in court. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals , U. It represents a landmark Supreme Court decision that changed the acceptance of scientific data in the courtroom. Before it, pretty much anyone could testify as an expert if they simply knew more about a particular subject than a layperson Frye Rule. That all dramatically changed with Daubert. In addition, scientific results do not always represent absolute truth. There is not always a scientific answer even if scientific procedures are utilized.
This allows forensic examiners the ability to reach qualified opinions and differences of opinions. Add to that the possibility that an individual examiner used poor technique or had a bad day, and you then develop an understanding of why Daubert became necessary. Daubert forces a testifying examiner to meet certain criteria before being allowed to testify.
Welcome to Drexler Document Laboratory, LLC
This article addresses the use of forensic document examin-ers FDEs in Florida will contests. The first decision is whether to retain an FDE. This decision turns on several issues, including the nature and strength of the claims, the quality of lay witness testimony, and whether the opponent will use expert testimony. Once the decision to retain an FDE is made, the practitioner must decide on the type of FDE to retain and whether the FDE will testify at trial or merely assist with trial preparation and consult during the course of the trial.
These considerations are integral to the successful use of an FDE in will contests. A will contest involving allegations of will-tampering or spoliation may lend itself to the use of an FDE.
Many intelligence officers, my colleagues and consultants. Free online dating analysis expert witnesses specializes in the date drew nearer, forensic experts.
Fisher Forensic Document Laboratory, Inc. Clients who utilize the Laboratory’s Consolidated Consultants CCc continues to deliver high quality expert witness and medical expert witness referrals nationwide since The second concept is based on measuring ink components that change with age. The analysis of solvents in ballpoint inks may be a useful parameter for determining the age of ink on paper.
For this reason this type of tag is commonly referred to as a florescent date tag. Expert witnesses who are available to consult and testify regarding ink dating may be found. Ink dating — fourth case example — The fourth example was a portion of evidence in a case that contained a mountain of ink dating analysis showing that some engineering notebooks were added to and written after the fact.
Sequencing of indented impressions and writings — Examining intersections areas where the visible ink lines cross the indentations may determine the order of writing and thus prove that a particular entry was added at a later time. The second ink dating approach analyzes the chemical composition of inks on a contested document with the aim to determine whether these inks as well as other materials used to produce the document — paper, inkjet printing ink, toner, stamp pad ink.
With this method the forensic analysis determines the components in the ink, compares them against a library of standards and then allows an opinion regarding the first date that particular ink was manufactured commercially available. This evidence was used in the criminal trial linking one of the suspects to the victim. The hole punch is approximately the size of a typewriter period and a full range of tests requires about CCc is the only referral service where you can view the full, If the universe of possible matches is at some point narrowed to one ink formulation, then an opinion can ink dating analysis expressed that the questioned ink matches the formulation from the library to the exclusion of all other formulations in the reference library.
Document Analysis: A Summary of Possibilities – Expert Article
Determining who authored or signed a particular document can be a challenge. While computer software has made it easier to tell when a word-processing file was created or modified by a particular machine, determining whether a handwritten item belongs to a particular writer remains difficult. Enter handwriting expert witnesses, who specialize in helping attorneys settle questions about written evidence.
Ink and Paper Analysis / Trace Evidence / Questioned Document Examination. It is possible to examine xerographically ink materials and determine the extent to.
Skip to search form Skip to main content You are currently offline. Some features of the site may not work correctly. DOI: Neither Frye nor Daubert solved the problem: what can be done? Kaufman Published Engineering. View via Publisher. Save to Library. Create Alert. Launch Research Feed. Share This Paper. Psychiatry Grigorios Leon Chapter 14 — Testifying.
Bekesinski v. R. – TCC: Expert report lacked evidentiary foundation – expert evidence inadmissible
Ink dating expert witnesses Good morning america dating expert Many intelligence officers, my colleagues and consultants. Free online dating analysis expert witnesses specializes in the date drew nearer, forensic experts. Lead story picture cvs health can challenge the very evidence, questioned document examiner with over listings below. Forensic examination qde is janet fenner masson. Find expert witness search by understanding the ink dating, which has provided court references for.
Purchase this study, and white papers.
The Report of the Expert Working Group for Human Factors in Handwriting Examination. NISTIR This publication The Testimony of the Forensic Document Examiner. For example, information such as ink dating, paper composition.
Cerca in archivio. Scrivi alla redazione Seguici anche su Facebook Iscriviti al feed rss. It is possible to examine xerographically ink materials and determine the extent to which they have been exposed to environmental conditions. This can provide an estimate of age. Additional examination evidence are being evaluated that concern the other referenced materials.
Forensic and chemical examinations can indicate the use evidence multiple typewriters, printers, papers or writing instruments in forensic preparation of a document. When additions are prepared ink the same materials that were used in the initial preparation of the dating then ink question actually becomes, “When were the additions made?
Ink and Paper Analysis / Trace Evidence / Questioned Document Examination
Richard T. In the course of his career he has examined thousands of disputed signature, handwriting and document cases, participated in numerous high profile investigations and testified in trials including the “Zodiac” homicides and the first terrorist attack on the World Trade Center in New York City. Picciochi possesses a background that integrates the natural sciences, forensic sciences and law enforcement investigations.
Picciochi specializes in the examination of signatures and has testified in state, federal and international courts. He will accept civil, criminal and administrative cases and offers his services to both Plaintiff and Defense attorneys. Curt Baggett is the 1 handwriting expert in the USA.
Ink Dating experts serve as expert witnesses and forensic consultants in California legal matters, and provide expert reports and testimony for judges, attorneys.
Ink Dating is done in two primary forms. The first ink dating method is the static approach, which determines when the ink being examined was manufactured. The second ink dating method is the dynamic approach, this method is to determine when the writing occurred, or in simple terms, how long the ink has been on the paper. The ink dating static approach is typically more useful as the difference between the date on the document and the present time increases.
Several different tests exist in this form of ink dating. These ink dating methods include the comparison of the examined ink to a known library of standards, commonly called the library approach, the detection of chemical date tags placed in the ink purposefully by the manufacturer, commonly called the date tag method, and also the determination of the type of ink writing instrument used. The determination of the type of writing instrument is probably the oldest method of ink dating.
This ink dating method primarily involves microscopic examinations and can also incorporate some basic chemical solubility testing. Some examinations can be performed on fountain pens to determine type of nib, type of ink and the first date of introduction of each of these. However, since this is a very small portion of the actual type of cases seen, we will concentrate primarily on more recent developments.
Other pages discuss the use of infrared to discriminate the differences between inks that visually and microscopically look identical. The next step would be the most basic ink dating form of thin layer chromatography TLC testing to determine if two or more inks are the same or different formulations.
Florida Bar Journal
Expert witnesses who are available to consult and testify regarding ink dating may be found here. The consultants found through this page may provide reports on forged checks, signatures, questioned documents, ink analysis, and forensic ink dating, as well as expert witness testimony on these and related issues.
You may limit your search for Ink Dating expert witnesses to a specific area by selecting a state from the drop down box. Featured Experts. Document examinations are provided in the following areas: handwriting, typewriter, photocopies,
as ink dating and analysis. As expert witnesses, handwriting experts can analyze information, form opinions, and prepare reports in a similar.
Full service laboratory including a state-of-the-art Video Spectral Comparator 4Plus for analyzing ink. Qualified as an expert in numerous State and Federal Courts. Typical casework involves handwriting identification, medical records examination, forgery and print process determination, and ink differentiation. TASA delivers the precision and speed you need when you are searching for the right document examiner expert witness for your case. Our experienced, regional referral advisors will discuss specific document examiner expert credentials with you, as well as the location, experience, and time frame you need.
Most referrals are made within 24 business hours. We provide background and fee information, forward expert resumes at your request, help arrange your initial phone interviews with document examiner authorities, and follow up to see if you require other experts. There is no charge unless you designate or engage an expert we refer. Since , The TASA Group has connected legal, insurance, law enforcement, and business clients with superior expert witnesses and consultants.
Contact us today for credible document examiner expert witnesses, by phone, email , or online request form. If you are a party in a case that requires an expert witness, please have your attorney contact TASA at Phone: